If you’re a coffee enthusiast, you’ve probably heard of Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee at some point or another. Its unique flavor has become so popular that people all around the world are spending hundreds of dollars on it.
Buying expensive coffee can be risky, though. To make sure you get your money’s worth, you’ll want to know which brands are trustworthy and how to tell what’s genuine. We’re here to help ensure you get the best authentic Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee money can buy.
At a Glance: Our Top Picks You Must Try
1. Peaberry Coffee (Best Overall)
2. Clydesdale Coffee (Chocolate Lovers Choice)
3. Magnum Exotics (Best Value)
4. Coffee Traders (Best Fruity Flavor)
5. Dancing Moon (Best Pre Ground Coffee)
- 1 What is Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee?
- 2 Jamaica Blue Mountain Peaberry Coffee
- 3 Jamaica Blue Mountain Clydesdale Coffee
- 4 Jamaica Blue Mountain Magnum Exotics
- 5 Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee From Coffee Traders
- 6 Jamaica Blue Mountain Coffee From Dancing Moon Coffee
- 7 How to Know it’s Genuine
- 8 What to Consider
- 9 Cozy’s Final Thoughts
What is Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee?
Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee beans, as their name suggests, grow in the Blue Mountains of eastern Jamaica. The high altitude and cool, high-precipitation climate are necessary for these incredibly special coffee plants to thrive.
Blue Mountain coffee has a unique flavor that some people describe as citrusy, chocolatey, and even a little bit nutty.
Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee is one of a kind and so special that the Coffee Industry Board of Jamaica has a regulation act to help prevent any knockoffs. They have a strict set of qualifications that all coffee beans must meet in order to receive the Board’s mark of approval.
If you have never tried Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee before let us indulge your taste buds by reviewing all your best options! You will not be disappointed!
Jamaica Blue Mountain Peaberry Coffee
Out of all the options on our list, our highest recommendation goes to Wallenford’s Jamaica Blue Mountain Peaberry Coffee.
We highly recommend going with whole beans if you own a coffee grinder, as this is the most effective way to extract the flavor. If not, their product page allows you to choose from drip grind, espresso grind, and French press. If you don’t own a coffee grinder we highly recommend you check out our review of the best grind and brew coffee makers on the market today.
These beans are 100% certified by Jamaica’s Department Of Agriculture. It is also Direct Trade, Kosher, and Rainforest Certified, making this a good sustainable coffee choice.
Peaberry Coffee is a medium roast with notes of floral, creamy, and even chocolatey flavors. It also has some Peaberry Coffee beans mixed in. Rest assured that this is only a small addition, and it will not dilute but instead enhance the flavor of the Blue Mountain coffee beans!
If you’re trying it for the first time, you can purchase their sixteen-ounce bag first. If you’re already familiar with Blue Mountain coffee, though, their options go as high as five pounds per bag.
Whether you’re a first-time Blue Mountain drinker or an experienced coffee enthusiast looking to restock your pantry, this product is an excellent choice.
Jamaica Blue Mountain Clydesdale Coffee
Do you like chocolate in your coffee? You’re in luck, because this Blue Mountain Clydesdale coffee is bursting with chocolatey flavor.
When you brew these coffee beans, you can expect a bit of a nutty taste. This mingles deliciously with the creamy cocoa flavors, making this a delicious experience for chocolate lovers.
Like the previous option, we recommend that you go with whole beans. However, you can choose from drip grind, espresso grind, and French press as well.
This coffee is medium roasted and sun-dried on concrete slabs. And of course, the beans originate from the high-altitude of the Blue Mountain range, making it 100% authentic.
With its eco-friendly packaging and Rainforest Alliance Certification, you can feel good when you purchase this coffee.
Unfortunately, you can only currently purchase these in eight-ounce packages. However, its small size, in addition to its fun and nifty packaging, makes it an excellent gift for those who have not yet experienced the flavors of Blue Mountain coffee.
Jamaica Blue Mountain Magnum Exotics
Wanting to experience the flavors of Jamaica’s Blue Mountains, but you’re working with a tight budget? While it won’t be quite the same as the other options on this list, we can still highly recommend you give Magnum Exotics a try.
This medium roast coffee is pretty affordable and full of flavor. When you brew yourself a cup of this coffee, you’ll taste the sweet cocoa-citrus flavor of Jamaica’s Blue Mountain coffee beans.
However, because it is a blend, these flavors may be slightly diluted by the presence of other beans. The bag only contains 20% Blue Mountain coffee beans, which are genuine, but there isn’t enough to give you the full experience that other brands might offer.
If you’ve never tried Blue Mountain coffee before, this could be a good product to start with. If you’d rather have a general idea of whether you’ll like Blue Mountain coffee before choosing something more pure (and by extension, expensive), it doesn’t hurt to purchase a cheaper blend like this one.
Experienced Blue Mountain drinkers, however, might be a little disappointed with this blend. If you’re looking for the full experience, we recommend a different item on this list.
Jamaican Blue Mountain Coffee From Coffee Traders
One of the best things about Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee is its unique citrusy flavor. If you’re looking for a cup of coffee where the fruitiness is most prominent, we recommend this 100% Blue Mountain blend from Coffee Traders.
You might also be pleased to hear that this blend has no fillers — it is 100% Blue Mountain coffee beans. This ensures all of the unique flavors of the Jamaican Blue Mountains can shine through, giving it a stronger citrusy flavor.
In addition, it has notes of cocoa flavor, and the result after you brew it is incredibly smooth.
When you purchase from the featured link, you can choose between pre-ground beans or whole beans. Both options are medium roast.
You also have the option to choose an eight-ounce package, making this convenient for people who are trying Blue Mountain coffee for the first time and are unsure whether they’ll enjoy it.
If the seal of certification on the package wasn’t enough, every order comes with a form indicating proof of origin. This can help you rest assured that you are getting your money’s worth.
Jamaica Blue Mountain Coffee From Dancing Moon Coffee
Do you want to enjoy the flavors of Blue Mountain Coffee, but you don’t like the hassle of grinding beans? We believe that Dancing Moon Coffee’s pre-ground Jamaican Coffee is a wise choice for you.
Like the previous option, this coffee is a 100% Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee blend, so you don’t have to worry about any fillers getting in the way of that unique, cocoa-citrus flavor. This particular blend also comes in k-cup size to brew using your favorite Keurig machine. Because of its convenience and pure flavor, it could be a good option for people trying this type of coffee for the first time.
You shouldn’t expect quite the same experience you’d get from freshly ground beans, but it’s safe to say this brand can still offer a delicious, authentic coffee experience.
This brand received certification from Jamaica’s official Coffee Board, so not only is it free of fillers, it is completely authentic. They even provide a photo of their certificate on the Amazon product page.
In addition, 5% of proceeds from your purchase will go towards helping wounded veterans. So you’ll get to drink some tasty coffee and do some good for those in need — it’s a win-win!
How to Know it’s Genuine
The main way to tell if a bag of these coffee beans is genuine is by checking the label. Every bag of authentic Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee will have the Coffee Industry Board’s seal of certification.
There are extra steps you can take to ensure that it’s genuine. If someone wants to rip you off, it’s pretty easy to slap on a fake seal.
You can check to see the percentage of beans in the bag of coffee if it’s a blend. If it doesn’t have the exact percentage, that could be a red flag. While there’s nothing inherently wrong with blends, the actual percentage of Blue Mountain coffee in the bag could be too small to be significant.
You should also read over the packaging before you purchase. If it indicates its origins are anywhere other than Jamaica, it is probably not authentic. Remember, this coffee bean does not grow outside of the Blue Mountains.
Finally, if you’re still not sure, you can always speak directly to the seller. Ask them if they have any kind of documentation for their coffee that can prove its authenticity. If they’re not trying to scam you, they shouldn’t have a problem showing verification.
What to Consider
Even if your coffee is genuine, your experience can vary from bag to bag.
Pre-Ground vs Whole Beans
There are pros and cons to pre-ground coffee and whole bean coffee. When it comes to Blue Mountain coffee beans, you’ll get the unique flavor either way, but the intensity and quality can vary.
Pre-ground coffee has a slightly different flavor than whole bean coffee, and it can go stale pretty easily. It’s also the same price as whole beans, so you shouldn’t choose ground coffee just to save money.
People who are used to ground coffee, however, might not notice the difference. As long as it doesn’t go stale, you can still have a positive experience.
If you have the means to prepare whole bean coffee, though, we highly recommend that you do! It’s worth the extra time and effort.
A lot of Blue Mountain coffee comes in a blend. Some people might see this as a downside, but in some instances, the additional coffee beans may pair well with the flavor of the Blue Mountain beans.
As long as there’s a high enough percentage of Blue Mountain coffee beans, you can expect to taste the flavors of this treasured Jamaican coffee. We recommend you choose something that has at least 30%.
Pre-Roasted vs Unroasted
Whether you choose pre-roasted or unroasted coffee beans is entirely a matter of preference.
In general, unroasted coffee tends to be a little bit cheaper than pre-roasted. But overall, the quality tends to be the same, and roasting coffee can add a bit more effort than it’s worth.
If you enjoy roasting your coffee and want to save a little money, then you can always opt for unroasted, but you shouldn’t expect much difference in quality or flavor. For more information check out our review of the best coffee rosters on the market today!
Cozy’s Final Thoughts
All of the coffee options we’ve recommended are likely to satisfy your tastebuds. If you’re having trouble settling on one, you should go for our utmost highest recommendation, the Jamaican Blue Mountain Peaberry Coffee. Its strong flavor and addition of Peaberry makes it a simply delicious brew. It’s a bit more pricey than the other options, but it’ll definitely be worth it.
Of course, it’s also important to consider your budget and personal preferences. Before making a decision, you can compare prices in the provided links. Be sure to consider other factors, such as flavor intensity and whether you want pre-roasted or pre-ground coffee.
In the end, as long as it’s authentic Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee, you can expect excellent flavor!